On October 26, 2026, the U.S. Department of Education's Student Privacy Policy Office announced investigations into North Monterey County Unified School District, Palo Alto Unified School District, and San Francisco Unified School District. The agency said the districts are accused of requiring students to complete "Wheel of Power/Privilege" and "Mapping My Identities" activities in ethnic studies courses without providing the parental notice and written consent required by the Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment. According to the department, these exercises ask students to disclose personal information including sexual orientation, gender identity, mental and physical health, family economic status, and race. (Source 1)
PPRA Requirements
The Protection of Pupil Rights Amendment, codified at 20 U.S.C. § 1232h, bars schools that receive federal funds from requiring students to participate in surveys, analyses, or evaluations that reveal information about eight protected categories. These include political affiliations, mental or psychological problems, sexual behavior or attitudes, illegal or antisocial behavior, critical appraisals of family relationships, legally recognized privileged relationships, religious practices, and income. The law requires prior written parental consent for such surveys. It also mandates that all instructional materials used in connection with such surveys be available for parental inspection and that local education agencies develop policies on inspection rights. (Sources 3, 4)
District Responses
Palo Alto Unified Superintendent Jason Glass said that both of the district's high schools confirmed students were not asked to complete the questioned activities. Glass stated that the wheel appears in the Ethnic Studies syllabus only as a teacher example labeled as such. The district is reviewing how lessons were taught and how parent requests to review materials were handled. (Source 2)
North Monterey County Unified School District said it conducted an internal investigation after receiving a letter from the Education Department and found no evidence supporting the claims. The district reported that the materials specifically referenced were not assigned, the activities reviewed did not require students to disclose information covered by the law, and parents and community members had opportunities to review the curriculum. (Source 5)
San Francisco Unified School District declined to comment on active investigations. A spokesperson stated that students are not required to share information they are uncomfortable disclosing and that all families were invited to review the Ethnic Studies curriculum when it became available. The district adopted the 'Voices' curriculum in April 2026, replacing content used since 2010. (Source 6)
Enforcement Context
The October 26 investigations expand the department's application of PPRA. In August 2026, the SPPO issued a Dear Colleague Letter establishing that mental health screening instruments that probe students' emotional well-being require prior written parental consent under PPRA. The letter stated that any survey administered that addresses one of the eight protected areas will be considered by the office as required, and that opt-out provisions do not satisfy the consent requirement for Education Department-funded surveys. (Source 8)
On October 5, 2026, the Education Department and the Justice Department jointly sent letters to all state attorneys general warning about noncompliance with PPRA regarding mental health screenings. The October 26 actions are the first known federal enforcement of PPRA against ethnic studies curriculum activities, according to the department's announcement. (Source 1)
Guidance Basis
The SPPO's October 2020 model notice (SPPO-21-01) summarizes PPRA requirements and distinguishes between surveys funded by Education Department programs and those that are not. The August 2026 Dear Colleague Letter revised that interpretation for administered surveys, stating that because students commonly feel obligated to participate when an authority figure administers a survey, the office would consider all such surveys to be required and subject to consent provisions. (Sources 8, 9)
California's Ethnic Studies Mandate
California's AB 101 (Education Code § 51225.3) requires pupils graduating in the 2029-30 school year and thereafter to complete a one-semester course in ethnic studies. School districts were required to offer at least a one-semester ethnic studies course starting with the 2025-26 school year. (Source 7)
