THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Beyond the headline
FORMATIVESPACES.COM

Cincinnati Public Schools faces Nov. 3 levy vote and a Nov. 30 state recovery plan that cannot count on levy money

The district seeks a five-year, 7-mill levy projected at about $66.3 million a year while the state requires a recovery plan due Nov. 30 that excludes that revenue. Officials project $20 million to $25 million more in annual cuts if voters say no.

A cityscape view across a wide river shows a skyline of various buildings under a blue sky with white clouds. A large metal truss bridge spans the river, and a bare tree branch is visible in the foreground on the left.
Cincinnati, Ohio. Shown for location context; this is not a photograph of the events described. Photo: Paul Armstrong from Cincinnati, USA / Wikimedia Commons. CC BY 2.0. Resized for display; social preview adds branding.
Positions eliminated in June 2026, by categoryCentral office81Social workers12Assistant principals10Counselors8
Original Research by FormativeSpaces.com
The June 2026 reductions totaled 111 positions, plus 3 more tied to ending International Baccalaureate programs. [6]

Cincinnati Public Schools is asking voters on Nov. 3, 2026, to approve a five-year, 7-mill operating levy projected to raise about $66.3 million a year, even as it drafts a state-ordered financial recovery plan that cannot assume any of that money. The Ohio Department of Education and Workforce placed the district in fiscal caution on Sept. 2, 2026, after projecting a $44.5 million budget deficit by fiscal year 2029. The recovery plan is due Nov. 30. The board is expected to vote on it Nov. 23, three weeks after the levy result is known.

The measure appears on the ballot as Issue 4. According to the district, it would generate $66,336,723 a year, or $245 per $100,000 of home market value, with collections beginning in January 2027. It is Cincinnati's first new operating levy request since November 2016.

$66,336,723Projected annual revenue from the five-year, 7-mill operating levy [1]

A recovery plan that cannot count the levy

The recovery plan is restricted to measures the board and administration can directly control, excluding revenue from a levy that has not yet been approved by voters, Formative Spaces reported. Board member Ben Lindy indicated that the plan must proceed while the levy campaign is underway, since the outcome of the vote remains uncertain.

The state issued both a deficit notice and a low balance advisory alongside the fiscal caution designation, WCPO reported.

$44.5 millionProjected budget deficit by fiscal year 2029 that triggered the state's fiscal caution finding [2]

What the district has already cut

CPS closed a projected $58 million gap in its fiscal year 2027 budget through staffing reductions, five furlough days, a 10 percent cut in non-personnel spending, tighter hiring controls, a reorganization of services, outside funding, and about $6.7 million in one-time resources. The board adopted the fiscal year 2027 general-fund budget at $634.6 million.

$634.6 millionGeneral-fund budget adopted for fiscal year 2027 [5]

In June 2026 the board approved eliminating 111 positions district-wide: 81 central office jobs, 12 social workers, 10 assistant principals, and 8 counselors. Ending International Baccalaureate programs removed 3 more, for 114 total. Those reductions accounted for roughly $13 million of the $58 million gap, and the five furlough days were estimated to save about $7.5 million. The 111 positions cut in June were overwhelmingly non-teaching roles.

The next round reaches classrooms

Superintendent Shauna Murphy indicated to the board that further spending reductions would affect services delivered directly to students. WCPO reported that she identified central office as about 14 percent of the current budget, meaning additional cuts would need to target school-level staffing and programs, and that prior reductions had already extended beyond supplies and materials to personnel.

Among the possibilities officials have listed if the levy fails, WKRC Local 12 reported: closing or consolidating schools, eliminating Montessori programs, ending the community learning center model, tightening transportation eligibility, reducing teaching positions and raising class sizes, charging pay-to-play fees for athletics, and cutting extracurricular programs. Murphy indicated that any programs not mandated by state law could be subject to reduction. The district has not said how many teaching positions would be eliminated.

According to Signal Cincinnati, the district would face $20 million to $25 million in additional annual reductions beyond the $58 million already cut for fiscal year 2027 if the levy fails, with comparable reductions needed in each subsequent year, leaving only state-required programs.

$20 million to $25 millionAdditional annual cuts officials project if the levy fails, on top of the $58 million already reduced for fiscal year 2027 [4]

How the state's oversight ladder works

Under Ohio Revised Code Section 3316.031, districts placed in fiscal caution get roughly 60 days to submit written proposals for correcting their finances. If the director of the Department of Education and Workforce finds the proposals unreasonable, the director may recommend fiscal watch to the Auditor of State. Fiscal watch can escalate to fiscal emergency, at which point a Financial Planning and Supervision Commission takes over the board's financial powers, including decisions about personnel and curriculum.

WLWT reported that fiscal emergency has already reshaped other Ohio districts, including Mount Healthy City Schools and a district near Akron, where state-appointed commissions took over financial decision-making from elected boards. CPS leaders have pointed to those cases as the outcome they are trying to avoid.

The district has been through part of this before. CPS filed a comparable state-required recovery plan in 2021 that the state accepted. The current leadership team has not previously navigated the fiscal caution process.

Cincinnati is not alone in the forecast. WCPO reported that 48 other Ohio districts project a negative cash balance in fiscal year 2029, and that 26 of them exceed the 5 percent threshold that placed CPS in fiscal caution. The financial pressure is associated with flat revenue, rising costs, a state funding formula that uses cost figures calculated in 2022, and a January 2026 property tax change that limits how much revenue grows from reappraisals.

48Other Ohio districts projecting a negative cash balance in fiscal year 2029, 26 of them above the 5 percent threshold [7]

The same request on other Ohio ballots

Dayton Public Schools has its own 7-mill levy request on the same Nov. 3, 2026 ballot, according to a Budget Committee briefing on the Cincinnati issue. That makes Dayton the other major Ohio urban district seeking new operating revenue this cycle, with both districts facing pressure from flat revenue and rising costs.

Reserves and tax burden in context

CPS ended fiscal year 2026 with $43.01 million in general-fund cash, an unreserved balance equal to 4.7 percent of a year's spending. The Ohio median is 36.2 percent. The district typically ends a fiscal year with 25 to 30 days of cash on hand, against a sound-practice benchmark of about 60 days and an ideal of about 90, WCPO reported.

Unreserved general-fund balance as a share of annual spending4.7%Cincinnati Public Schools36.2%Ohio median
Original Research by FormativeSpaces.com
Cincinnati's unreserved balance at the end of fiscal year 2026 compared with the median Ohio district. [9]

The district also spends less per student than Ohio's other large urban systems: 12 percent less than Cleveland Metropolitan School District and 15 percent less than Columbus City Schools, according to the Budget Committee briefing.

The same briefing puts Cincinnati's effective residential millage for current expenses at 38.07 mills, against an Ohio median of 24.39, which places it in the 95th percentile statewide. Total voted operating millage is 63.79 mills, in the 82nd percentile. Median property tax on owner-occupied homes is $3,146, in the 77th percentile, and takes 5.8 percent of household income, in the 96th percentile.

38.07 millsCincinnati's effective residential millage for current expenses, against an Ohio median of 24.39 [9]

What the evidence shows, and what it leaves open

The state's guidance describes the sequence from caution to watch to emergency but does not assess whether caution plans keep districts from escalating. The research material reviewed for this story contained no published evaluation of that question. The framework has been applied to multiple Ohio districts, according to the department's summary.

The Budget Committee's millage and property tax figures describe the cost burden Cincinnati voters carry relative to other districts. That data does not evaluate whether the levy or the recovery plan will succeed.

Sources

  1. Cincinnati Public Schools. Information About the CPS Property-Tax Levy on the November 3, 2026 Ballot View
  2. WCPO. CPS could face $44.5M deficit by 2029, the state of Ohio warns View
  3. Formative Spaces. Cincinnati Public Schools under state fiscal caution; recovery plan due Nov. 30 without levy revenue View
  4. Signal Cincinnati. Cincinnati schools make their case for proposed $66.3M levy View
  5. Cincinnati Public Schools. CPS Board Places Five-Year, 7-Mill Property-Tax Levy View
  6. Formative Spaces. Cincinnati Public Schools faces levy vote and state recovery plan deadline amid fiscal caution View
  7. WCPO. CPS leaders discuss what state fiscal caution status, $44.5M deficit could mean View
  8. WKRC Local 12. Tri-State school district outlines upcoming levy costs, consequences View
  9. Budget Committee. Cincinnati Public Schools – November 2026 School Tax Issue Briefing View
  10. Ohio Department of Education and Workforce. Summary of Requirements for Fiscal Caution View
  11. WLWT. Cincinnati Public Schools faces $44 million deficit ahead of state reporting deadline View
Cincinnati Public Schools faces Nov. 3 levy vote and a Nov. 30 state recovery plan that cannot count on levy money | Formative Spaces