THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Beyond the headline
FORMATIVESPACES.COM

Education Department's 'Defend the Spend' justification requirement takes effect Nov. 1, 2026

Under a Sept. 28 memorandum, all ED grant recipients must submit 255-character justifications for every G5 payment request starting Nov. 1, 2026. Associations warn of delays; ED points to a low flag rate at DOL.

A large, modern building with many rectangular windows is seen from a street corner. Cars are visible on the road in front of the building, and trees line the street.
Headquarters of the U.S. Department of Education in Washington, D.C. Shown for institutional context. Photo: ajay_suresh / Wikimedia Commons. CC BY 2.0. Resized for display; social preview adds branding.

Starting November 1, 2026, every recipient of U.S. Department of Education grant funds will have to submit a written justification for each payment request through the G5 system. The requirement comes from a September 28, 2026 memorandum by Murray Bessette, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary and Acting Assistant Secretary for the Office of Planning, Evaluation and Policy Development, titled "Mandatory Written Justifications for Payment Requests to Implement Executive Order 14222." The memo was sent to all ED grant recipients, including state education agencies and school districts that draw down federal funds [1].

The justification is capped at 255 characters and must include the program name, expense categories and amounts, a date range for the earliest and latest expenses, and no personally identifiable information. If the justification triggers what the department calls "procedural or internal control concerns," the recipient gets an email asking for additional information, and the payment request is not approved until the clarification is accepted. In certain cases, such as duplicate requests or unallowable costs, ED can reject the justification outright [1].

Opposition from associations

The policy has drawn pushback from several education groups. Sasha Pudelski, director of advocacy at AASA, The School Superintendents Association, said the requirement would create additional administrative work for states and districts, requiring states to develop guidance, provide technical assistance, and review submissions. She called the justifications duplicative of existing accountability measures, including detailed application and budget approvals, monitoring requirements, audits, and fiscal reviews, and said the added paperwork would increase administrative burden without meaningfully improving accountability, redirecting limited administrative capacity away from teaching, learning, and student services [3]. AASA posted a September 29 issue update warning that the new requirements could create delays and administrative burden for districts [5].

The National Association of State Directors of Special Education (NASDSE) said in a statement to K-12 Dive that the requirement will affect students across all schools, especially students with disabilities. The group warned that any delay in federal disbursement would directly impact services and potentially deprive vulnerable students of a free and appropriate public education, including children who attend private schools but receive public funding [3].

Iowa's UEN issued a "Federal Call to Action" on October 6, urging Iowa school districts to contact their U.S. Senators and Congressional Representatives before November 1 to press ED to resist the additional requirement. UEN called the step burdensome for school districts, noting that the expenditure of federal funds is highly regulated, with oversight before the request via an application process and down to the dollar after expenditures are reported [4]. The Association of Educational Service Agencies (AESA) posted a similar alert on October 6 [7].

Precedent at other agencies

The Defend the Spend process is not new. The U.S. Department of Labor, which has an interagency agreement to manage grants for ED's Office of Career, Technical and Adult Education, has already been using the justification process. A senior ED official told K-12 Dive that DOL has processed 7,600 payments worth $2 billion since September 2025, with only six flagged for needing further explanation, a flag rate of about 0.08 percent [3].

0.08 percentFlag rate for DOL-processed ED payments under the existing Defend the Spend process, according to a senior ED official cited by K-12 Dive. [3]

The ED memorandum states that for grants co-administered by partner agencies through interagency agreements, Defend the Spend implementation is already complete, and written justifications have been required since those grants were first administered through partner systems. The Nov. 1 G5 rollout, then, extends an existing practice rather than creating an entirely new one [1].

Defend the Spend protocols have also been in effect at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, where ED's Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services grants are expected to move via an interagency agreement. EducationCounsel reported that a federal court has paused the justification requirements for some HHS grantees, raising legal questions about the policy's viability as it extends to ED grants [6][8].

Legal and operational questions

EducationCounsel's legal analysis raised questions about how the Defend the Spend requirement complies with existing grant regulations. Those regulations set specific requirements and processes for when prior approvals may be required, typically for grantees with a history of non-compliance, and specify that such requirements must be promptly removed once the conditions that prompted them have been satisfied. EducationCounsel noted that OMB's parallel proposed regulations are currently prohibited from finalizing by the terms of Congress's Continuing Resolution, which maintains federal funding through December 11, 2026 [6][8].

The ED memorandum itself states the process should not change the timeline for processing a payment request, unless the request triggers procedural or internal control concerns. It also advises grantees to plan accordingly and allow sufficient time for processing in the instance where additional review or clarification may be required [1]. The only available operational data point cited by ED officials is the DOL experience, which covers a narrower grant portfolio than all ED programs and does not constitute an independent evaluation of the policy's impact on payment timeliness or administrative burden across the full range of ED grantees [3].

The ED grant management webpage now hosts Defend the Spend resources, including step-by-step guidance and walkthroughs for submitting written justifications in both the PMS and ED G5 Grantee Dashboards, confirming ED is proceeding with implementation ahead of the Nov. 1 effective date [2].

Analysis

Analysis by , written after the reporting above was filed.

The same Defend the Spend framework already lost in court at HHS.

HHS adopted DTS in March 2025 under the same Executive Order 14222. When it used the process to restrict $10 billion in grant drawdowns to five states, those states sued in SDNY. Judge Broderick granted a preliminary injunction on February 6, 2026, finding plaintiffs likely to succeed on APA claims. HHS rescinded the restrictions in July 2026. ED's September 28 memo extends DTS to all G5 grants but does not acknowledge that the HHS version already collapsed under legal challenge.

G5 drawdowns already take 1-3 business days. The justification adds a layer with no stated turnaround.

Routine G5 payment processing runs one to three business days. The new justification adds a review layer where ED can hold any payment pending a clarification email, with no stated deadline for resolving the exchange. ED points to DOL's 0.08 percent flag rate across 7,600 payments as reassurance, but that portfolio is narrower than all ED programs and has not been tested against the full range of grantees including small and rural districts.

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of Education (via COENET). Defend the Spend Memorandum to Grantees, Sept. 28, 2026 View
  2. U.S. Department of Education. Manage Your Grant View
  3. K-12 Dive. Education Department wants grantees to 'defend the spend' View
  4. UEN (Iowa). Federal Call to Action: Defend The Spend & E-Rate - October 6, 2026 View
  5. AASA, The School Superintendents Association. Education Funding View
  6. EducationCounsel (Nelson Mullins). EducationCounsel ALERT: FSTC Regulations, Courts Rule Against Grant Terminations...Defend-the-Spend Requirement... View
  7. Association of Educational Service Agencies (AESA). New 'Defend the Spend' Requirements Could Create Delays and Administrative Burden for Districts View
  8. EducationCounsel. E-Update for October 5, 2026 View
  9. U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York. New York v. ACF, et al., 26-CV-172 (VSB) Opinion & Order View
  10. U.S. Department of Education, Federal Student Aid. Requesting and Managing Title IV Funds, 2026-2027 Federal Student Aid Handbook View