Sens. Patty Murray and Tammy Baldwin sent an Oct. 13 letter to Education Secretary Linda McMahon accusing the department of "frontloading" competitive grants — paying out multiple years of a multiyear award in a single lump sum rather than funding a larger number of grants annually. The senators estimate the practice has withheld approximately $630 million across roughly 35 grant programs, including K-12 literacy, teacher preparation, and child care for student parents.
What the senators allege
The letter, published by the Senate Appropriations Committee, provides specific program-level examples. For the Innovative Approaches to Literacy program, Congress provided $30 million for fiscal year 2026. The Education Department's own grant competition notice had indicated the agency expected to make 25 to 35 new awards, according to the senators. The department instead announced only four new awards and set aside $13 million for future years of those grants — money the senators said could have supported roughly 25 additional awards.
The Education Department's grant awards page for the IAL program confirms the historical pattern the senators cite: 12 new awards were made in 2023 and 29 in 2021 at the same or smaller total funding levels. More than 200 IAL grants have been awarded since the program's inception in 2012, according to the American Library Association.
For the Child Care Access Means Parents in School program, Congress provided $75 million in FY2026. The department had projected 148 awards but made only 40 new ones and set aside $53 million for future years, according to the senators. Inside Higher Ed reported that the administration awarded $71.4 million to 40 CCAMPIS grantees.
The letter also cites teacher preparation: the Teacher Quality Partnership program made 12 grants with $59 million of its $70 million appropriation set aside for future years; Supporting Effective Educator Development was limited to 16 new awards; and the Augustus Hawkins Centers of Excellence Program set aside more than $14 million for future years. The Institute of Education Sciences made no new awards from competitions posted in 2024 or from FY2026 competitions, the senators note, and they wrote that the administration has effectively halted the agency's operations since January 2026.
The department's rationale
Education Department spokesperson Ellen Keast responded on Oct. 14 with a statement reported by K-12 Dive. She indicated that the department is supporting grantees it considers to be of the highest quality and returning education to the states.
How frontloading compares with past practice
Prior to the second Trump administration, the Education Department rarely terminated discretionary grant funding except for compliance-related reasons such as financial mismanagement or missed performance targets, according to grantmaking experts cited by Higher Ed Dive. The Council for Exceptional Children noted that frontloading was previously used only in rare cases before this administration.
The most recent previous update to the Education Department General Administrative Regulations, finalized under the Biden administration in August 2024, was described as a routine modernization. Its published summary of major provisions enumerated only technical updates, ESEA alignment, streamlined selection criteria, and continuation award procedure clarifications, with no reference to termination-for-convenience authority. That 2024 rule did not include a termination-for-convenience provision or changes to continuation award authority of the kind now proposed in the August 2026 NPRM.
Proposed rule changes and legal backdrop
On Aug. 24, 2026, the Education Department published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to amend EDGAR. The proposed rule would revise section 75.901 to expressly authorize the Secretary to terminate discretionary awards "for convenience" and would revise section 75.253 to give the Secretary broad discretion in making continuation determinations, including the authority to issue a partial award, provide funding in installments, or delay the release of funds. The Federal Register notice states the department intends to finalize the regulations in late 2026.
The NPRM itself estimates the proposed changes would reduce spending by $186,363 annually over the next 10 years, a marginal figure that Higher Ed Dive noted is consistent with the senators' argument that the rule's primary purpose is to expand termination authority rather than achieve efficiencies.
The senators warn that if the proposed EDGAR changes or parallel OMB uniform guidance revisions take effect, the department could terminate frontloaded funds before they reach students, effectively voiding FY2026 funds that Congress appropriated.
Multiple federal courts have already ruled against the department's prior grant terminations. In 2025, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington ruled that the department's termination of school-based mental health grants was unlawful, finding that the existing regulatory framework does not support the department's position that multiyear grants may be discontinued based on political preferences rather than grantee performance, according to K-12 Dive. The department was required to make new continuation decisions, but subsequent litigation over the department's replacement approach remains pending.
In July 2026, the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts granted summary judgment to a coalition of 20 states, three governors, and the District of Columbia, holding that a provision in the Uniform Guidance (2 CFR section 200.340(a)(4)) does not authorize agencies to cancel grants based on policy priorities identified after the grants were awarded. Other courts have similarly read the language as referring to goals in place at the time of award, while the D.C. District Court has read it more broadly, according to a legal analysis by Nixon Peabody. This split means the legality of the department's approach to terminating grants for policy reasons remains contested across jurisdictions.
