THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Beyond the headline
FORMATIVESPACES.COM

CEMD scan finds 44 percent of large U.S. districts lack formal AI policy, with professional learning nearly absent

A scan of 219 large school districts found that 44 percent have no AI policy and only 10 percent of existing policies address staff training. A growing number of states, including Ohio, Virginia, Utah, and Maryland, now require districts to adopt AI policies, while most still rely on voluntary approaches.

A grand white stone building with a large dome and columns is viewed from the bottom of a wide staircase. The words "STATE OF UTAH" are visible on the facade.
The Utah State Capitol complex. Shown for state policy context. Photo: Robert Cutts from Bristol, England, UK / Wikimedia Commons. CC BY 2.0. Resized for display; social preview adds branding.

Almost half of the largest U.S. school districts have not adopted any formal policy on the use of artificial intelligence, according to a landscape scan published by the Center for Education Market Dynamics. The scan examined publicly available documents from 219 districts that together serve more than 14.6 million students, roughly 29 percent of all public school students, across 43 states. It found that 44 percent of the districts had no AI policy adopted or in progress as of the start of the 2026-27 school year.

44Percent of 219 large U.S. school districts with no formal AI policy as of the start of the 2026-27 school year, according to the CEMD scan. [1]

Among the districts that did have policies, only 10 percent of the policy documents referenced professional learning or training for staff. The scan found that existing policies were often scattered across multiple documents, webpages, or frameworks rather than forming a coherent single policy, and few were confirmed to have been developed with community involvement. The tone of most policies emphasized restrictions over structured guidance for productive integration.

10Percent of district AI policy documents that referenced professional learning for staff, per the CEMD scan. [1]

The scan detected no statistically significant relationship between the presence of an AI policy and district characteristics such as size, demographics, urban or rural location, or curriculum selection. The finding suggests that policy adoption so far has not tracked with the structural factors that often shape education technology decisions.

States shift from guidance to mandates

While most states continue to rely on voluntary guidance or no framework, a small but growing number have enacted laws requiring districts to adopt AI policies. Ohio’s revised code section 3301.24, effective September 2025, required the state to develop a model policy and obligated every school district, community school, and STEM school to adopt its own policy by July 1, 2026. Maryland’s SB 720 (the Artificial Intelligence Ready Schools Act), effective June 2026, requires each local school system to adopt an AI policy aligned with state guidance, designate a central-office AI coordinator, and use a state-developed rubric when evaluating AI tools for procurement.

Virginia’s HB 1186 and SB 394, taking effect July 2026, require the state to issue guidance covering student data privacy under FERPA and COPPA, teacher training, transparency, and data-processing agreements that prohibit using student data to train external AI models, according to a compilation by TrueMadeAI. The statute requires school boards to establish policies consistent with that guidance but sets no calendar deadline. Utah’s HB 273, effective July 2026, requires the state board to publish model balanced-technology and AI-use policies by December 2026, with local education agencies required to adopt policies by July 2027. Utah’s law mandates parent notification for classroom generative AI use, prohibits biometric surveillance and psychological profiling, requires LEA approval of student-facing AI tools, and mandates staff training, with the possibility of withholding digital literacy funds for noncompliance.

Mandates versus guidance

A separate analysis of 122 districts and schools across 38 states by EdSurge and the AI and Education Studio found that only 15.6 percent explicitly referenced state guidance in their own policy documents, despite 63 percent being in states with officially published AI guidance. The analysis concluded that mandatory state guidance drives district adoption more reliably than advisory frameworks and that states relying on voluntary guidance saw inconsistent local adoption. In contrast, states such as Massachusetts, whose 2026 guidance according to TrueMadeAI explicitly leaves implementation decisions to local leaders, provide frameworks without requiring district adoption.

Research evidence points to slow and uneven adoption

Earlier peer-reviewed research found an even lower baseline. A content analysis of 9,229 U.S. K-12 districts published by Researcher.Life and Shaping Education Policy found that as of May 2024 only 14.13 percent of the districts that had identifiable policies had an AI policy. The study characterized the results as documenting the initial phase of AI policy formation in U.S. schools.

14.13Percent of U.S. K-12 districts with identifiable policies that had an AI policy as of May 2024, according to a content analysis published by Researcher.Life and Shaping Education Policy. [7]

A survey by the Center on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE) of state education agencies found that most states had not developed coherent AI approaches. Among 28 surveyed states, about half had updated standards for AI literacy, but fewer than half had issued mandated policies for districts or assisted with procurement.

Sources

  1. Center for Education Market Dynamics (CEMD). K–12 AI Policy: How Districts Are Navigating Guidance, Practice, and a Rapidly Changing Landscape View
  2. Ohio Laws. Section 3301.24 - Ohio Revised Code View
  3. Maryland General Assembly. 2026 Regular Session - Senate Bill 720 Chapter 634 (Artificial Intelligence Ready Schools Act) View
  4. Tenet (TrueMadeAI). State K-12 AI Laws and Guidance (2026) View
  5. EdSurge / AI and Education Studio. Study: The National AI Policy Landscape in K–12 Education View
  6. Utah Legislature. HB0273 - 2026 Session View
  7. Shaping Education Policy / Researcher.Life. Artificial Intelligence Policies in K-12 School Districts in the United States: A Content Analysis View
  8. CRPE (Center on Reinventing Public Education). Leading Through Uncertainty: State Approaches to AI in K–12 Education View