More than half of New York's 678 school districts lack formal, board-adopted artificial intelligence policies, according to an analysis published October 13 by New York Focus. The news outlet built an AI crawler to scrape district websites and third-party school board platforms, then manually verified the results and contacted districts that appeared to have no policy. The analysis found that around 270 districts have formal AI policies, most supporting what they describe as responsible AI use to improve instruction. The New York State Education Department has not yet issued comprehensive statewide guidance, leaving districts to navigate student data privacy, academic integrity, and family notification on their own.
New York Focus reached out to roughly 400 districts for which no formal AI policy was found online. More than 70 confirmed they did not have a board policy in place, and 39 of those said they planned to develop one during the 2026-27 school year. Some districts without formal policies are already using AI regularly. In Nassau County's Rockville Centre Union Free School District, which has no board policy, elementary students demonstrated programming an AI chatbot to take on the persona of Amelia Earhart for classroom questioning, as presented at a board meeting.
Statewide guidance absent as districts navigate on their own
NYSED spokesperson Karen Male told New York Focus that the governor has signaled focus on responsible use of digital tools and that the department continues to develop comprehensive statewide guidance to support emerging technologies in schools. No statewide K-12 AI framework has been issued. Meanwhile, New York City Public Schools, the state's largest district, implemented a moratorium on student-facing generative AI for grades 2K through 8 for the 2026-27 school year, with limited use in high schools. High school students may only use five approved, vetted programs: Quill, Edia, Brisk Teaching, Playlab, and Intel AI-Ready Schools. All high school students must complete two 45-minute AI literacy modules covering how AI works, data privacy and bias, and appropriate uses. Schools must notify families when students participate in approved programs. AI may not be used for grading, behavior monitoring, or decisions about placement, promotion, or graduation.
Two pieces of proposed legislation address the policy gap. New York State Assembly bill A06972, introduced in January 2026, would create an AI working group within the education department to develop guidance and a model policy addressing academic integrity, pupil data privacy, parent access to information students enter into AI systems, and procurement standards. The bill had not been enacted as of the analysis date. State Senator Andrew Gounardes's FOCUS Act, introduced in August 2026, would require ed tech companies to register with the state attorney general before offering products to school districts, demonstrating compliance with state and federal education laws, absence of distracting features, and proof from at least one independent study that products improve student academic performance.
National pattern mirrors local findings
The New York findings reflect a national pattern. A September 28 landscape scan by the Center for Education Market Dynamics examined 219 districts across 43 states serving more than 14.6 million students, or 29 percent of U.S. public school students. The scan found that 44 percent of districts have no formal AI policy adopted or in progress. It found no statistically significant relationship between the presence of a policy and district size, demographics, locality, or curriculum selection. The scan also found that only 10 percent of policy documents referenced professional learning or training, and that policies tend to emphasize restrictions as districts respond to new AI uses.
As of June 2026, according to a report from the Center for Innovation, Design, and Digital Learning, eight states had enacted legislation requiring state agencies to develop AI guidance or requiring local school districts to adopt formal AI policies: Idaho, Illinois, Maryland, Ohio, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Utah, and Virginia. A report from the Center on Reinventing Public Education, based on survey responses from 29 state education agencies collected from November 2025 through April 2026, found that only 25 percent of states (7 of 28) had issued or planned to issue official regulations or mandated policies for districts. Fifty-four percent had curated a list of vetted AI tools, and 43 percent had assisted or planned to assist with procurement. CRPE noted that states are more comfortable with actions that signal direction and support local discretion than with operational support. A separate EdSurge study building an AI School Policy Database coded 122 districts and schools across 38 states and found that 44.3 percent were at a conditional, teacher-directed level, while 27.9 percent were at a guided integration level, 17.2 percent restrictive, 7.4 percent prohibited, and only 3.3 percent pro-innovation. The study found that legally mandated state guidance drives adoption more reliably than advisory frameworks, and that only 15.6 percent of districts explicitly referenced state guidance in their own policy documents.
Research shows fragmented policy landscape
Peer-reviewed research confirms the fragmented nature of AI governance in K-12 education. A study published in Sage Journals analyzed publicly available AI policies from 424 districts in Kentucky, North Carolina, and Tennessee. It found that a minority of districts offer comprehensive guidance while most provide minimal direction, particularly regarding ethics and pedagogical considerations. The study also identified cross-state differences and economic disparities in AI policy quality. The authors noted the study covers only three southeastern states and may not generalize nationally. Another Sage Journals study conducted a content analysis of state-level AI policy guidance documents from 40 states and territorial jurisdictions issued between 2023 and 2026. It found that ethics and data privacy dominate current policy approaches, while equity considerations and educator capacity-building receive moderate attention, and stakeholder trust and ongoing monitoring remain underdeveloped. The study identifies policy gaps in developing comprehensive AI governance for K-12 education. The CEMD landscape scan, which also functions as a research evidence source, found no statistically significant relationship between policy presence and district characteristics, suggesting policy adoption is not driven by measurable district traits. The scan relied on publicly available documents, which may miss internal guidelines not posted online.
