Proposal details
On Nov. 5, 2026, Pennsylvania Department of Education officials presented a proposal to the State Board of Education that would lower the minimum scores required for students to be labeled advanced on the PSSA and Keystone exams in math and reading. The proficient threshold would remain unchanged at 1,000 on the PSSA scale, but nearly all grade levels would see a reduction in the score needed for the top performance level, according to a presentation by Dr. Carrie Rowe and Amy Lena at a special board meeting listed on the board's agenda. The State Board is scheduled to vote on the proposal Nov. 19.
The proposed changes mark the first revision to PSSA math and reading cut scores since 2015, when the state adopted more rigorous PA Core Standards. Brian Campbell, director of PDE's Bureau of Curriculum, Assessment, and Instruction, told the board that adopting new standards for reading and math is still years away and that the department is recommending new cut scores as an interim adjustment. The adjustment would apply to both the K-8 PSSA and the high school Keystone exams.
Campbell said the changes would result in more students being classified as advanced and would have mixed impacts on the share of students classified as below basic. A department presentation stated that while the number of proficient students would remain statistically consistent with historical expectations, the new thresholds would make it difficult to compare student performance across years.
Precedent and process
The revision follows a similar but separate cut-score update for science assessments. In September 2026, the State Board of Education unanimously approved new cut scores for PSSA Science in grades 5 and 8 and for the Biology Keystone exam after overhauling science standards under the STEELS framework. That action created a precedent for adjusting cut scores subject by subject after a standards revision.
Pennsylvania's Keystone exam cut scores date to July 2011, when the board adopted the four-level performance scale for Algebra I, Biology, and Literature with proficient set at 1,500 on a 1,200-to-1,800 score scale. The PSSA reading and math cut scores currently in use were set in 2015. The proposed changes represent the second adjustment in a little over a decade for some subjects.
Regulatory and research context
Pennsylvania regulations require the Department of Education to use widely accepted psychometric procedures to establish cut scores and to present them at a public board meeting at least two weeks before a vote, according to 22 Pa. Code § 4.51a. The same regulation requires the department to consult with educators, students, parents, and citizens. Campbell told the board that nearly 90 Pennsylvania educators worked on the cut score review. The regulatory framework establishes the process but does not evaluate whether specific thresholds are optimal.
The most recent published state assessment results, from the 2024-25 school year, show PSSA math proficiency at 41.7 percent and PSSA ELA proficiency at 49.9 percent, according to the Department of Education. Keystone Algebra I proficiency stood at 44.3 percent, Literature at 62.1 percent, and Biology at 49.4 percent. The 2025 PSSA results by grade show wide variation in performance: Grade 3 math had 23.6 percent advanced and 25.1 percent below basic, while Grade 8 math had 10.0 percent advanced and 43.9 percent below basic.
The delay in finalizing cut scores has contributed to months-long delays in releasing 2026 test results in Philadelphia, where families applying for selective high school slots do not yet know whether their children qualify for some schools' lotteries. Applications are due Nov. 24.
