SUNDAY, OCTOBER 4, 2026
Beyond the headline
FORMATIVESPACES.COM

Tennessee board moves to let teachers who fail exams take shorter vendor tests instead of full retakes

The proposed policy change would allow candidates who fail a content-area licensing test to pass a component-based exam, portfolio, or remediation module. The state issued 6,579 emergency credentials last school year.

A large, light-colored stone building with a prominent central tower and classical columns stands on a grassy hill under a partly cloudy sky. Flags fly from the top of the tower, and a bare tree stands in front of the building.
The Tennessee State Capitol complex. Shown for state policy context. Photo: Kaldari / Wikimedia Commons. Public domain. Resized for display; social preview adds branding.

The Tennessee State Board of Education is advancing a proposed amendment to Policy 5.105 that would allow teacher candidates who fail a content-area licensure exam to pursue vendor-developed alternatives instead of retaking the full test. The May 2026 draft of the policy lists four approved alternate scoring opportunities, a change from the May 2025 version which contained no such language.

The four approved alternatives are Pearson Series Flex, a portfolio-based submission; Pearson Testlets, a component-based assessment; ETS Praxis Bridge, a targeted remediation module; and ETS Praxis Steps, another component-based assessment. Under the proposed policy, a candidate must first attempt a standard assessment before using any alternate opportunity. The General Assessment Requirements section was updated to state that candidates must submit qualifying scores on required assessments or on vendor-developed alternate opportunities.

Licensure changes follow edTPA phaseout

The proposal is the second major change to Tennessee's teacher licensure assessments in two years. The State Board phased out the edTPA pedagogical assessment requirement effective July 1, 2026, for candidates completing approved educator preparation programs. The Educator Licensure Review Committee recommended the phaseout in October 2024, determining that the existing pedagogical assessment requirements did not adequately serve teacher candidates, preparation programs, and school districts in Tennessee.

Pearson announced its Series assessment was adopted by the Tennessee State Board of Education on February 27, 2026, effective March 10, 2026, at a promotional rate of $99 per test through August 31, 2026, with free retests provided after three failed attempts. The company's announcement framed the model as a way to reduce financial and persistence barriers to entry but did not cite prior state adoptions of the same approach.

Emergency credentials remain high

6,579Emergency credentials issued by Tennessee in the 2024-25 school year [4]

The policy change arrives as Tennessee continues to rely heavily on emergency credentials to staff classrooms. The state issued 6,579 emergency credentials in 2024-25, comprising 5,529 temporary permits for unlicensed teachers and 1,050 endorsement exemptions for licensed educators teaching outside their area of expertise. That number rose from 6,007 the previous year.

At the same time, teacher vacancies in Tennessee declined 43 percent, from 1,434 in 2023-24 to 817 in 2024-25. The number of vacancies filled by emergency hires increased by more than 300 percent over the last five years, and rates of new graduates from Tennessee teacher training programs have declined in recent years.

Support and concern over the proposal

J.C. Bowman of Professional Educators of Tennessee supported the proposal. He maintained that the proposal would not reduce standards, as candidates would still need to prove subject-matter competency through an approved method. He also noted that the Praxis exam tests content that is not aligned with Tennessee's own curriculum standards.

At least one State Board of Education member expressed concern about relaxing licensure requirements. Supporters including teacher advocacy organizations have argued the change removes barriers without lowering standards.

The State Board advanced the proposed policy for further discussion at its May 2026 meeting, noting that more changes could be introduced before a final reading.

Update - October 4, 2026

On July 15, 2026, the State Board held a member learning session at which ETS and Pearson presented detailed specifications for their proposed alternative assessment options. ETS disclosed that Praxis Bridge modules would cost $50 each and be available only to candidates who narrowly miss passing—within one standard error of measurement of the state's cut score—with an option for states to adopt three-year retroactive eligibility. Praxis Steps, described as modular testing initially available for the new Elementary Education Fundamentals assessment, would let candidates bank scores from individual sections and retake only the portions they failed [14].

The Nashville Banner reported that the State Board of Education is scheduled to vote on the Policy 5.105 amendment on final reading in November 2026 [13]. The Department of Education noted at the July session that approximately half of states nationwide have adopted some or all of these vendor-developed alternatives as a strategy for addressing teacher shortages [13].

Analysis

By the Formative Spaces Newsroom, written after the reporting above was filed.

Massachusetts ran the same portfolio alternative for three years. The workforce impact was modest.

Massachusetts launched MTEL-Flex in October 2020, a Pearson-administered portfolio submission available to candidates who fell short on the state licensing exam. An AIR evaluation in its second year found that candidates who used the Flex were about 3 percentage points more likely to pass than those who retook the full exam, but the difference in actual licensure and employment outcomes was not statistically significant. It became the most popular retake method among eligible candidates. The teachers who used it were slightly more likely to be Black or Hispanic than those who passed the traditional exam.

A quarter of candidates who fail the content exam never try again. That is who this targets.

Tennessee's content assessment pass rate was 88.6 percent within two attempts in the 2023 state report card. First-attempt pass rates on content knowledge tests ran closer to 67 percent, and 25 percent of candidates who failed on the first try never retested, according to NCTQ data. For candidates of color, that walkaway rate hit 35 percent. The 6,579 emergency credentials the state issued last year are partly a consequence of that pipeline loss. This policy is aimed at the candidates who give up rather than retake.

Tennessee's proposal has no near-miss threshold. Massachusetts restricted its version to candidates who barely failed.

Massachusetts limited its MTEL-Flex to candidates who scored within one standard error of measurement of passing. Tennessee's proposed Policy 5.105 requires only that a candidate attempt the standard assessment first, with no minimum score threshold to access the vendor alternatives. A candidate who scored far below passing could use the portfolio or component-based path. Board member Krissi McInturff, a Washington County elementary school principal, said at the May meeting the proposal goes "too far." Whether Tennessee adds a score floor before the final reading is the detail to watch.

Sources

  1. Tennessee State Board of Education. Professional Assessments for Tennessee Educators Policy 5.105 (May 19, 2026 clean draft) View
  2. Tennessee State Board of Education. Professional Assessments for Tennessee Educators Policy 5.105 (May 30, 2025 clean draft) View
  3. Chalkbeat Tennessee. Are big changes coming to Tennessee teaching license tests? View
  4. Chalkbeat Tennessee. Tennessee private school teachers without a degree could get emergency waivers View
  5. WATE. TN teacher vacancies down as non-traditional paths help fill gaps View
  6. Pearson VUE. Tennessee Expands Teacher Licensure Options with New Pearson Assessment View
  7. trendbits.blog. Tennessee State Board of Education Licensure Review Committee recommends phasing out edTPA View
  8. NewsChannel 5 Nashville. Tennessee considers alternative pathways for teacher candidates who struggle with the Praxis exam View
  9. Tennessee State Board of Education. 2023 Tennessee Educator Preparation Report Card (State Report) View
  10. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. Alternative Assessment Pilot Evaluation Interim Second Year Assessment (AIR) View
  11. Massachusetts Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. MTEL-Flex Eligibility Requirements View
  12. National Council on Teacher Quality. Tennessee Teacher Licensure Test Pass Rates View
  13. Nashville Banner. State Board of Education considers easing teacher licensure View
  14. Tennessee State Board of Education. ETS Slide Deck – Empowering Candidate Success Through Innovation (July 15, 2026 Member Learning Session) View