THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026
Beyond the headline
FORMATIVESPACES.COM

Study finds immigration enforcement fears disrupted schooling in Chicago and Charlotte months after operations

A new Urban Institute study based on interviews with 34 Latino mixed-status families documents persistent school absences, altered transportation, and academic strain, with Chicago schools providing more support than Charlotte under different state policies.

A cityscape features a collection of tall buildings, including a dark, wavy skyscraper and a very tall, dark building with two spires. In the foreground, a large white Ferris wheel stands near a body of water with boats, and a complex of lower buildings with glass roofs.
Chicago, Illinois. Shown for location context; this is not a photograph of the events described. Photo: quinntheislander / Wikimedia Commons. CC0. Resized for display; social preview adds branding.
Parents who said their school provided supports to navigate immigration enforcement79%Chicago47%Charlotte
Original Research by FormativeSpaces.com
Nearly all Chicago parents (15 of 19) described school-based supports such as Know Your Rights workshops, ICE monitoring, emergency planning, counseling, and excused absences. In Charlotte, fewer than half of parents (7 of 15) described such supports, and some reported limited flexibility around absences and inconsistent responses across schools. [2]

The Urban Institute released a study October 14, 2026, that brings parent voices to a growing body of evidence connecting immigration enforcement to disruptions in K-12 education. Authored by Hamutal Bernstein, Laura Betancur, Diana Guelespe, and Julio Salas, the study is based on 34 semi-structured interviews with Latino mixed-status families in Chicago and Charlotte, conducted between April and June 2026, months after high-visibility enforcement operations in both cities. The 34 parents represented the experiences of 92 children, 82 of whom were U.S. citizens [1].

Key findings

92Children whose experiences were represented in the study interviews; 82 were U.S. citizens. [2]
34Parents interviewed: 19 in Chicago, 15 in Charlotte. Most parents were undocumented themselves; 22 households included undocumented spouses or partners. [2]

Nearly half of parents said their children had stayed home from school for at least a few days because of concerns about immigration enforcement. Some described absences of one to two weeks or up to a month. Over half of parents reported concerns about sending children to school or accompanying them, and nearly half altered transportation routines, shifting responsibility to older children, relatives, other parents, or paid ride-sharing apps. Over half of parents described psychological strain from the enforcement environment affecting children's academic performance, including declining grades, lack of motivation, and difficulty focusing. Half of parents reported seeing declining grades for at least one child. Nearly all parents said they reduced their own time in public spaces, and many kept children from parks, after-school activities, or sports [2].

Policy context differed between the cities

Illinois and Chicago have established frameworks that limit local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement, including the Illinois Trust Act and the Welcoming City Ordinance. These laws mandate protections in schools, universities, courthouses, and hospitals. The study also identifies the Safe Schools for All Act (HB1312), which requires Illinois schools to establish procedures for responding to law enforcement agents on-site. Charlotte operates under North Carolina law, a Dillon's Rule state where local authority is more constrained. Mecklenburg County ended its 287(g) agreement with ICE in 2018, but the state legislature mandated that all sheriffs cooperate with ICE (2024) and required state agencies including the Highway Patrol to sign 287(g) agreements with ICE (2026). The Urban Institute study found that nearly all Chicago parents described school-based supports, compared with fewer than half in Charlotte, suggesting that state-level policy may enable or constrain the school-level response [2].

Previous research on enforcement and education

22 percentIncrease in daily student absences in five California Central Valley school districts linked to immigration raids in January and February 2025, with larger increases among pre-K students and effects persisting for weeks after the initial raid. The study was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. [4]

The Urban Institute study joins a body of peer-reviewed research that has quantified similar patterns. A study of 287(g) programs in North Carolina found that activation of the program increased absences for Hispanic students by nearly a day, driven by rises in chronic absenteeism, with no measured effect on White or Black students [3]. A study of the Secure Communities program found that its activation was negatively associated with Hispanic students' English language arts achievement, but that students in sanctuary jurisdictions were not impacted, suggesting local protective policies can buffer enforcement effects [5]. A working paper using Florida student-level records found that the 2025 surge in interior enforcement reduced test scores for both U.S.-born and foreign-born Spanish-speaking students, with effects concentrated in middle and high schools [7]. A study of California CORE districts linked county-level immigration arrests to declines in attendance, achievement, and school climate for Latinx students; a one standard deviation increase in arrests corresponded to a 5 percentage point increase in absenteeism among secondary Latinx students. The authors noted these are associations, not causal estimates [6]. Research in New Orleans schools found that local enforcement increased the White-Hispanic test score gap by 0.27 to 0.52 of a standard deviation in math and 0.28 to 0.52 in reading [9]. A study using nationally representative kindergarten cohorts linked county-level deportation orders to declines in Latinx math achievement, with strongest effects in the Trump administration years [8].

Parents' recommendations for schools

Parents interviewed for the Urban Institute study recommended that schools strengthen communication about local enforcement changes and available supports, help families address transportation challenges, offer remote learning when travel is unsafe, provide emotional support and counseling, and ensure consistent responses across schools rather than leaving individual staff to organize on their own [2].

Sources

  1. Urban Institute. Impacts of Heightened Immigration Enforcement on Children's Education View
  2. Urban Institute. Impacts of Heightened Immigration Enforcement on Children's Education (PDF) View
  3. IES (ERIC). The Effect of Immigration Enforcement on School Engagement: Evidence from 287(g) Programs in North Carolina View
  4. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Recent immigration raids increased student absences View
  5. PLOS One. Apprehension and educational outcomes among Hispanic students in the United States: The impact of Secure Communities View
  6. SAGE Journals (AERA Open). Immigration Arrests and Educational Impacts: Linking ICE Arrests to Declines in Achievement, Attendance, and School Climate and Safety in California View
  7. NBER Working Papers. The Effects of Immigration Enforcement on Student Outcomes in a New Era of Immigration Policy in the United States View
  8. American Journal of Education (University of Chicago Press). From Court to Classroom: Deportation Proceedings and Reading and Math Achievement for Elementary Students from 1998 to 2016 View
  9. SAGE Journals (AERA Open). Out of the Class and Into the Shadows: Immigration Enforcement and Education Among U.S.-Citizen and Foreign-Born Hispanics View