On October 26, 2026, the Joint Subcommittee to Study Elementary and Secondary Education Funding approved a plan to hire an expert consultant to study replacing Virginia's 52-year-old Standards of Quality (SOQ) K-12 funding formula with a student-based model. The scope of work allows up to 24 months for completion. The subcommittee's agenda listed a presentation of the request for proposal scope of work by Holly Coy, chief of staff for the Virginia Department of Education, according to the official meeting agenda and a report by the Virginia Mercury [1][2].
The current formula and its shortcomings
Virginia's SOQ formula allocates money based on staffing ratios, a method that the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission (JLARC) evaluated in a July 2023 report [3]. JLARC identified two policy options for changing the formula: fully replacing the staffing-based model with a student-based formula, estimated to cost $1.17 billion above fiscal year 2023 levels, or partially replacing calculations for special education and English learner funding, estimated at $520 million above FY23 [3]. JLARC also found that the formula under-calculates the number of special education teachers and aides and English learner teachers. For fiscal year 2023, the SOQ formula calculated 13,300 special education teachers were needed, which was 93 percent of the number actually employed by school divisions and 66 percent of what workgroups estimated was needed [4]. For English learners, the formula calculated 2,600 teachers, which was 77 percent of the number employed and 48 percent of what workgroups estimated was needed [4].
The state has increased ongoing K-12 education funding by just over $4 billion, or 50 percent, from fiscal year 2023 to fiscal year 2028, according to a staff report presented to the subcommittee and reported by the Virginia Mercury [2]. The increases include $1.5 billion for teacher salaries, $537.5 million for school support staff, $273.2 million for at-risk students, and $126.8 million to establish and expand dedicated special education funding [2]. The Virginia Mercury also reported $106.9 million in additional funding for English learner teachers and reading specialists, which the subcommittee presentation classified separately from the ongoing increases cited above [2].
National context
Virginia is one of only nine states that use a staffing-based K-12 funding formula, according to JLARC's 2023 report [3]. Thirty-four states use student-based formulas, and seven states use hybrids or other approaches [3]. The report cited the Education Commission of the States and Tennessee's Investment in Student Achievement formula as examples of student-based models but did not include outcome evaluations of those states' formulas [3].
Evidence on formula design
JLARC's evaluation concluded that a well-designed student-based funding model would be more accurate, more transparent, and easier to maintain over time than the current staffing-based formula [3]. The evaluation did not assess whether student-based formulas produce different educational outcomes; its conclusions are about formula design characteristics such as simplicity and transparency [3]. JLARC also found that the SOQ formula does not adequately account for higher-needs students, with state funding for at-risk, special education, and English learner students below levels determined necessary in cost studies from other states [3]. The complexity of the formula, which uses more than 60 staffing ratios and student weights for special education calculations alone, made it difficult to pinpoint the exact cause of the under-calculation [3][4].
Next steps
Once the Virginia Department of Education finalizes the draft request for proposal, it will publish the document and accept bids for 30 days. The agency expects to select a consultant and begin work during the January 2027 General Assembly session, according to Holly Coy, as reported by the Virginia Mercury [2]. Lawmakers will then have an opportunity after the session to provide further input on policy factors built into the funding model. Sen. Mamie Locke, re-elected chair of the subcommittee, indicated a preference for completing the study by December 2027, when Gov. Abigail Spanberger presents her biennium budget requests, rather than using the full 24 months available [2]. Del. Cia Price, a committee member, supported the committee's decision to advance the proposal [2].
