Cincinnati voters on Nov. 3 approved a five-year, 7-mill operating levy, the first new operating levy for Cincinnati Public Schools in almost a decade. The measure, Issue 4, is projected to generate roughly $66.3 million annually, with collections beginning in January 2027. But under Ohio Department of Education and Workforce rules, the district's mandated financial recovery plan, due Nov. 30, cannot count that revenue. The plan must be a contingency based only on spending cuts the board can enact without new tax money.
The Ohio Department of Education and Workforce placed the district in a precautionary financial state in early September after its first required financial forecast for fiscal year 2027 showed a projected deficit of $44.5 million by fiscal year 2029. The notification letter told the district it could not assume new levy revenue in its written recovery plan. The completed workbook, narrative, and board resolution must be submitted by Nov. 30.
Existing cuts
The board had voted 4 to 3 in June to eliminate 111 positions, including central office staff, social workers, assistant principals, and counselors. It also approved five unpaid furlough days for all employees, a 10 percent reduction in non-personnel spending, and the end of the International Baccalaureate program. The CPS Board of Education adopted a balanced $634.6 million general fund budget for fiscal year 2027, closing a projected $58 million budget gap through those measures, spending and hiring controls, service reorganizations, and limited one-time resources. The specific cuts approved in June saved roughly $13 million, leaving more than $40 million that was closed through other actions.
The state's demand
The $44.5 million deficit projected for fiscal year 2029 is the reason for the fiscal caution designation. The district's forecast shows expenditures growing at an annual rate of 1.78 percent while revenue grows at 0.26 percent. The forecast identifies rising "Other Uses" costs as a primary driver, projected $47.7 million higher annually than historical averages. Without the new levy, the district's cash balance would turn negative by fiscal year 2029.
Precedent in Ohio
Ohio's fiscal oversight law establishes three tiers: fiscal caution, fiscal watch, and fiscal emergency. If a district fails to produce an acceptable plan, oversight intensifies. Mount Healthy City Schools and a district near Akron have already reached the third tier, where a state-appointed commission assumed financial decision-making authority. The district navigated a similar state-required recovery plan in 2021 that the state accepted. Treasurer Michael Gustin noted that this is the first time the current leadership team has worked through the fiscal caution process.
Cincinnati is the only one of the state's three largest urban districts to impose system-wide unpaid furlough days as a cost-saving tool. The first system-wide furlough day was held in August, and a second in September, closing all buildings and canceling classes, meals, and after-school activities. Other large urban districts in Ohio have used different approaches to address budget shortfalls.
The uses of a contingency plan
Treasurer Michael Gustin told the board that 48 other Ohio districts were projecting negative cash balances in fiscal year 2029, with 26 of those over the 5 percent deficit ratio that triggered CPS's fiscal caution status. Board President Brandon Craig described the options in the submitted plan as existing to satisfy the state's requirement and that they may not result in the cuts actually occurring. Gustin said an amended version could be filed with the state if the levy passed.
Unverified and tracking
The Cincinnati Federation of Teachers alleges that the five furlough days violate the district's labor contract, which guarantees pay for 191 work days. The union stated an intention to challenge the furloughs as a contract violation. Two independent news sources have reported the claim. No filed grievance, labor board ruling, or court decision has been reported to confirm the challenge.
